Ella Lawson is the chief executive at Rome Bank,
a commercial banking enterprise. On
behalf of the bank, Rome will be
providing funding to a manufacturing
enterprise seeking to expand its operations. During her visit to the manufacturer’s factory, Lawson overhears
two employees on the production floor discussing
the likelihood of their employer’s inability to carry out expansion. Lawson
holds shares of the enterprise and decides to sell her holding and reject providing financial support. Lawson is
most likely in violation of the CFA Institute Standard of Professional Conduct relating to:
- A. Loyalty, prudence, and care.
- B. Diligence and reasonable basis.
- C. Material, nonpublic information.
The correct answer is B.
Lawson is in violation of the standard relating to diligence and
reasonable basis. This is because the discussion between the two production
employees and any information shared is
not credible enough to base her investment decision on. Given that these
individuals lack seniority, it is less likely they have access to confidential information. Therefore basing
her financing and share disposal decisions on information, which is not
credible will result in a decision, which lacks a reasonable and adequate
basis. Lawson is not in violation of the standard concerning material nonpublic
information. The specificity of the information, the extent of its difference
from public information, its nature, and its reliability are key factors in
determining whether a particular piece of information is material; the less
reliable information is, the less likely it is to be material. As discussed
above, the fact that the production employees are discussing a strategic issue whose
likelihood of occurrence is uncertain makes the information nonmaterial.
mincemeat23 said:Shouldn’t it be ‘On behalf of the bank, LAWSON will be providing…’?
You are right! We could also just delete “On behalf of the bank”. We try to change a few things here and there not to have the same material as in our question bank, but some mistakes might occur. Thank you for pointing out the issue and good luck with the exam!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.