- This topic has 5 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated Sep-1812:13 am by
mitch895.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
Up::5
Thanks @hairyfairy
Seems strange that the curriculum would use an approximate when simply grossing up each currency’s “price” by their rate of inflation seems (at least to me) to be an easier and more logical approach.
Maybe I’ve overplaying the significance of this (or likelihood of getting this kind of question on the L3 exam) but I’d had to drop 2 or 3 points because I used the wrong method of calculation! 🙂
-
Up::4
Here’s another example from Investopedia:
Assume that the U.S. is the foreign country and that Japan is the domestic country. The current spot exchange rate is S0 = 115 yen per dollar ($1 per ¥115.00). The expected annual inflation rate for the U.S. is 4.89%, and the annual expected Japanese inflation rate is 6.23%. Compute the approximate expected spot rate and the expected spot rate one year from now.
Answer:
Because Japan is the domestic country we have:S0 = 115 yen per dollar. (1 + Iy) is 1.0489, and (1 + Ix) is equal to 1.0623.
The approximation method would indicate that the yen should decline against the dollar by: (Iy – Ix) =(1.0489 – 1.0623) = -0.0134 = -1.34%
So the value of the yen relative to the dollar would be expected to decline to
(1 – 0.0134) × 115 = Â¥113.46 per $
We can calculate the rate more exactly as:
S1 = (1.0489) / (1.0623) × 115 = ¥113.55 per $
-
Up::3
@hairyfairy is right – the multiple choice would make sure that if you were using a ‘more accurate’ way to calculate, you should never lose points. In the essay, again you should receive full points
-
-
Up::1
I think it’s a matter of what’s the approximate way of doing it (which CFAI sometimes use, confusingly enough) and the ‘true’ way of doing it.
Your way of multiplying/dividing seems to be to be the ‘true’ way of calculating, whereas the use of just the differential of 5.52% is a quick approximate way of doing it.
In the actual exam the multiple choice should be set up in a way that accepts both (slightly different) answers. The options would probably be something like:
“The amount of Canadian dollars trading for 1 Euro at the end of the period is closest to:”
- C$1.38
- C$1.31
- C$1.42
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.